top of page
sweeteners_edited.jpg

The Sweetener Spectrum: Using Honey, Maple Syrup, and Molasses in Place of Granulated Sugar

Not All Sugars Behave the Same!

Swapping dry granulated sugar for a liquid sweetener like honey or maple syrup is not a simple 1:1 trade. In fact, you are fundamentally changing the chemistry of the recipe!

​

Liquid sweeteners introduce crucial differences—extra moisture, often a touch of acidity, and simpler sugar molecules—that drastically alter the final texture, structure, and color of your baked goods. Understanding these functional shifts is the key to successful substitution. This article will explain the essential adjustments needed when you swap dry sugar for liquid gold.

The Core Differences from Granulated Sugar

When substituting a liquid sweetener for neutral, dry granulated sugar, you must account for three major changes:
 

  1. Extra Moisture: Liquid sweeteners are naturally 18% to 35% water. This added liquid changes the consistency of your dough or batter, affecting how much it spreads and how tender it becomes.
     

  2. Acidity (The Baking Soda Boost): Many natural liquid sweeteners (especially molasses and some honeys) are slightly acidic. This sourness is vital because it will immediately react with baking soda, which is often needed to give your baked goods an extra lift.
     

  3. Moisture Retention & Browning: Liquid sweeteners contain simpler sugars (like fructose) that are excellent at holding onto moisture after baking. This results in superior tenderness, chewiness, and a crust that browns much faster and deeper than one made with granulated sugar alone.

Honey Dripping Jar
Image by Nadine Primeau

Sweetener Deep Dive

Each liquid sweetener brings its own unique set of characteristics to your recipe:

​

  • Honey: Sweeter than granulated sugar due to its high fructose content. Its natural acidity and superb moisture-retaining abilities result in an intensely tender and moist product that will brown quickly.

​​

  • Maple Syrup: Has the highest water content of the three. It provides a unique flavor but is slightly milder in sweetness. The high moisture is great for tenderness but can lead to a denser final texture if the other liquids in the recipe aren't reduced.

​​

  • Molasses: Highly acidic, intensely flavored, and dark in color. Its high mineral content makes it a heavier ingredient that creates the darkest, fastest-browning crusts. It is essential for traditional dense goods like gingerbread and pumpernickel.

The Substitution Rule (Key Adjustments)

To successfully substitute 1 cup of granulated sugar with a liquid sweetener, you must make two key adjustments:
 

  1. Reduce Liquid: Reduce the other liquids in the recipe (milk, water, etc.) by approximately 1/4 cup per 1 cup of liquid sweetener used to balance the added moisture.
     

  2. Adjust Leavening/Temperature:

    • Acidity Check: If using an acidic sweetener (honey/molasses) in a recipe that doesn't call for baking soda, add 1/4 teaspoon of baking soda to the dry ingredients. This will activate the leavening and balance the acidity.

    • Lower Temperature: Reduce the oven temperature by 25 degrees F (~15C) to slow down the browning process and prevent the moisture-rich crust from burning before the center is cooked through.

Image by Jakob Owens

Sugar Selection

Liquid sweeteners are valuable structural tools. They increase moisture, introduce acidity (affecting lift), and produce a tender, chewy result due to their simpler sugars.

​

Next time you substitute, remember you are not just sweetening; you are changing the moisture level and the lift. Choose your liquid sugar intentionally to achieve your desired color, texture, and rise—and enjoy the complexity!

bottom of page